Requirements review — non-operative

Approved Requirements Review

Status: non-operative substantive-pass review. This is a map of implementation and unresolved choices, not an assertion that the draft is ready for ratification.

Approved instruction	Revised destination and result
1. Electoral/caucus structure	Articles 4, 13, and 20; every district voter receives all three ballots; caucuses attach to candidates and seats; confidential community endorsement; overlapping identities handled by voluntary candidate choice. Usual resident population and enumeration safeguards are settled; enumeration methods and authentication details are delegated.
2. Assembly size and thresholds	Articles 4 and 20; authorized membership, upward rounding, simultaneous caucus and total requirements; initial configuration in Schedule A; adjustment safeguards in Article 13. Arithmetic checked at the initial size and 500 district sizes.
3. Executive formation	Article 5; protected Prime Minister/ministry/no-confidence threshold, recurring negotiations and ballots, constructive successor, restricted interim authority; portfolios relocated to proposed government law.
4. Judicial appointments	Article 10 Section 7 and Sections 2–3; three equal Commission components, public qualified shortlists, unchanged confirmation threshold, neutral temporary service, independent removal finding. Implementing procedures are delegated to protected organic law.
5. Due process	Article 2 Section 17 consolidates liberty, counsel, proof, defense access, timely independent hearing, evidence challenge, administrative fairness, review, and remedies; Article 10 preserves inquisitorial institutions and existing public-defense resources.
6. Government deception	Article 2 Section 18 and Article 20; prohibited coercive deception and official false reporting, candid treatment of vulnerable people, supervised lawful exceptions, presumptive invalidity, and distinct remedies/referrals.
7. Social and humanitarian rights	Article 2 Sections 8 and 14; progressive broader rights distinguished from immediate necessities, nondelegable custodial provision, and narrowly evidenced actual physical scarcity.
8. Responsibility and culpability	Article 2 Section 19, Articles 10, 11, 14, and 20; objective violation and State remedies separated from personal culpability; participation and mental state required; order-givers independently accountable; no published-ruling strict liability.
9. Return and restitution	Article 3; entry/belonging/citizenship independent of property claims, descendant eligibility distinct from succession, flexible proof and no DNA requirement, protection against new homelessness, State financial responsibility. Inherited Property Claims remains reserved.
10. Enduring guarantees	Article 12; immutable principles and essential rights, amendable institutional forms, two approvals, protected amendments and replacement, narrow judicial invalidation. Continuation settles amendment voting, timing, petitions, and Court voting; replacement mechanics remain reserved; referendum timing is now settled.
11. Transition	Transition Section 1a and Sections 2–8; preconstitutional Protocol/Conference, equal three-component Council, no retroactive self-legitimation, limited oversight powers, fair findings, objective completion and automatic dissolution, equivalent implementation permitted.
12. Sacred sites	Article 2 Section 9 and Article 19; equitable access with neutral proportionate arrangements, specialized civilian security under ordinary law and independent oversight. Physical arrangements and training detail preserved as proposed regulations.
13. Emergency/war/treaties	Articles 6, 11, 16, and 20; each-caucus authorized majorities, active renewal and oversight, public expiring war authorizations and withdrawal, treaty review, narrow technical-agreement exception, UDHR correctly classified.
14. Relocation/classification	Separate constitutional schedules, proposed laws/regulations, commentary, reservations, and records; exact original source retained and all 680 source units accounted for. Legacy website differences separately preserved.
15. Reserved matters/translation	Central register includes population basis, Yoma 22b accommodation, indirect enumeration and confidentiality, inherited title and lawful heir, and additional unapproved implementing choices. No Arabic/Hebrew legal translations supplied.
16. Verification and handoff	Local build/check, meaningful consistency checks, source and PHP preservation, link and visual review, complete changed-file package and patch. PHP/database runtime checks unavailable; no PDF source exists. Global paragraph renumbering, deployment, publication, push, and merge excluded.

Continuation decisions

Decision	Current destination / result
1 Amendment quorum	Article 4 Section 3: required affirmatives establish participation; no special quorum or reduced denominator.
2 Timing	Article 12 Section 3: ninety days, identical text, material-change six-month restart.
3 Court	Article 12 Section 6: two-thirds full authorized membership, narrow grounds, written reasons, ordinarily challenge-based.
4 Referendum	Article 12 Section 4: majority valid votes, no floor or communal classification; both protected caucus approvals remain.
5 Petition	Article 12 Section 4: ten percent nationally, formal consideration only, two-year objective-effect bar and expedited review. Civil Service separate at five percent nationwide.
6 Organic laws	Article 20 and explicit delegations: majority each caucus for enactment/amendment/repeal, constitutional subordination and review.
7 War	Article 11 Section 7: 24-hour notice, 72-hour publication, seven-day/earlier authorization, 60-day maximum, 14-day reporting, active renewal and withdrawal.
8 Reductions	Article 13 Section 6: successive regular enumerations, alternatives, enhanced review, each-caucus approval, prior Court certification, future election and pending-proceeding protection.
9 Sacred sites	Article 19 Section 2: full-membership two-thirds plus delegation majority; affected-delegation permanent-change protection; limited temporary safety exception and anti-manipulation.
10 Descendants	Article 3 and Article 20: equal minor adoption/equivalent relationships; independent eligibility, anti-status manipulation and adult-adoption limits; inheritance separate.
11 Classification	Central register and supporting proposals distinguish delegated implementation from constitutional reservations; originals preserved, duplicate snapshots externally archived.
12 Records	Ledger retains all 680 units, historical source and prior-pass files; continuation change record separately tracks before/after text.
13 Verification	Existing checks retained and continuation checks added; local rendering and baseline patch replay required; PHP/database unavailable.

Latest approved policy continuation

Decision	Destination and result
1 Referendum timing	Article 12 Section 4: 60–120 days after certified second approval; identical text; material-change cancellation and full six-month/two-approval restart. Replacement unaffected.
2 Civil Service petitions	Article 14 Section 3: five percent nationally, no communal quotas/lists/totals, review only, existing approval threshold retained.
3 Transition Council	Transition Section 2: fifteen members, five each; vacancies/removal safeguards; routine 8 overall/2 each, consequential 10 overall/3 each; full denominators and automatic completion.
4 Readiness	Transition Section 8: all defense/monetary categories, founding public Plan, objective testable time-bound measures, no perfection or benchmark manipulation.
5 Population	Article 13 Section 6: usual resident population, specified inclusions/exclusions, residence edge cases delegated, voter eligibility separate.
6 Enumeration	Article 13 Section 6 and Article 20: protected law, indirect religious accommodation, privacy/data separation, expert review; no State religious ruling or universal method claim.
7 Inheritance	Article 3 and Article 20 inherited-property text unchanged; no approved model or automatic title.
8 Archive	Complete prior-pass archive external to repository overlay; precise records and compact hash evidence retained live.
9 Verification	Updated existing checks for newly superseded reservations, added policy checks, clean baseline cumulative replay and package/archive hashes.

Only inheritance, Ratification Protocol/first appointments/founding authority, and convention/replacement mechanics remain inline constitutional reservations. Translation/equivalence review and the supporting succession contingency also remain outstanding. Technical enumeration and Plan measures remain delegated work. Structure is coherent for further substantive review; final global numbering and exhaustive numerical-reference audit remain deferred.